The hard part is over--you’ve found yourself a soul mate; everything that comes after should be as easy as a PB & J! Distract them from them hunger pangs by asking them how they like to make their signature sandwich.
Plus, you get two costumes in one! That’s hard to beat.. Everyone has a unique style, like a PB & J fingerprint--from crustless, to double-layered peanut butter, to wheat bread or white! That’s almost as good as a perfectly made PB & J (cut on a diagonal, of course) that has just the perfect proportion of jelly to peanut butter and nothing spilling out of the sides.